In another example of multi-disciplinary engineers producing a technology that could aid electrical systems, a group of mechanical and chemical engineers at MIT have converted a plastic material from a thermal insulator into a thermal conductor. This offers support for the idea that electrical engineering students should take basic courses in other engineering disciplines. It is becoming apparent that new technologies require inputs from multiple engineering sources.
The book Multidisciplinary Systems Engineering by J.A. Crowder, et. al describes the multi-disciplinary approaches to knowledge. As the book notes: “Multidisciplinary Engineering research literature clearly argues for development of strategies that can transcend and bridge the knowledge of any one given engineering discipline to another and engineers to enhance research collaboration between disciplines. Increasingly, cross and multi-domain research is more commonplace.”
MIT’s team of multi-disciplinary engineers developed a polymer thermal conductor—a plastic material that, however counterintuitively, works as a thermal conductor, dissipating heat rather than trapping it. The new polymers, which are lightweight and flexible, can conduct 10 times as much heat as most commercially used polymers.
Plastics efficiently trap heat, which may be an advantage in something like a coffee cup sleeve. But this heat-trapping property is less desirable in products such as plastic casings for laptops and mobile phones that can overheat, in part because the plastic coverings trap the heat that the devices produce.
“Traditional polymers are both electrically and thermally insulating,” says Yanfei Xu, a postdoc in MIT’s Department of Mechanical Engineering “The discovery and development of electrically conductive polymers has led to novel electronic applications such as flexible displays and wearable biosensors.
“Our polymer can thermally conduct and remove heat much more efficiently,” Xu continues. “We believe polymers could be made into next-generation heat conductors for advanced thermal management applications, such as a self-cooling alternative to existing electronics casings.”
Xu and a team of postdocs, graduate students, and faculty have published their results in Science Advances. The team includes Xiaoxue Wang, who contributed equally to the research with Xu, along with Jiawei Zhou, Bai Song, Elizabeth Lee, and Samuel Huberman; Zhang Jiang, physicist at Argonne National Laboratory; Karen Gleason, associate provost of MIT and the Alexander I. Michael Kasser Professor of Chemical Engineering; and Gang Chen, head of MIT’s Department of Mechanical Engineering and the Carl Richard Soderberg Professor of Power Engineering.
Engineers at MIT have developed a polymer thermal conductor—a plastic material that works as a heat conductor, dissipating heat rather than thermally insulating it. (Image: Chelsea Turner/MIT)
If you were to zoom in on the microstructure of an average polymer, it wouldn’t be difficult to see why the material traps heat so easily. At the microscopic level, polymers are made from long chains of monomers, or molecular units, linked end to end. These chains are often tangled in a spaghetti-like ball. Heat carriers have a hard time moving through this disorderly mess and tend to get trapped within the polymeric snarls and knots.
And yet, researchers have attempted to turn these natural thermal insulators into conductors. For electronics, polymers would offer a unique combination of properties, as they are lightweight, flexible, and chemically inert. Polymers are also electrically insulating, meaning they do not conduct electricity, and can therefore be used to prevent devices such as laptops and mobile phones from short-circuiting in their users’ hands.
Several groups have engineered polymer conductors in recent years, including Chen’s group, which in 2010 invented a method to create “ultradrawn nanofibers” from a standard sample of polyethylene. The technique stretched the messy, disordered polymers into ultrathin, ordered chains—much like untangling a string of holiday lights. Chen found that the resulting chains enabled heat to skip easily along and through the material, and that the polymer conducted 300 times as much heat compared with ordinary plastics.
But the thermal insulator-turned-conductor could only dissipate heat in one direction, along the length of each polymer chain. Heat couldn’t travel between polymer chains, due to weak Van der Waals forces—a phenomenon that essentially attracts two or more molecules close to each other. Xu wondered whether a polymer material could be made to scatter heat away, in all directions.
Xu conceived of the current study as an attempt to engineer polymers with high thermal conductivity, by simultaneously engineering intramolecular and intermolecular forces—a method that she hoped would enable efficient heat transport along and between polymer chains.
The team ultimately produced a heat-conducting polymer known as polythiophene, a type of conjugated polymer that is commonly used in many electronic devices.
Hints of Heat in All Directions
Xu, Chen, and members of Chen’s lab teamed up with Gleason and her lab members to develop a new way to engineer a polymer conductor using oxidative chemical vapor deposition (oCVD), whereby two vapors are directed into a chamber and onto a substrate, where they interact and form a film. “Our reaction was able to create rigid chains of polymers, rather than the twisted, spaghetti-like strands in normal polymers.” Xu says.
In this case, Wang flowed the oxidant into a chamber, along with a vapor of monomers—individual molecular units that, when oxidized, form into the chains known as polymers.
“We grew the polymers on silicon/glass substrates, onto which the oxidant and monomers are adsorbed and reacted, leveraging the unique self-templated growth mechanism of CVD technology," Wang says.
Wang produced relatively large-scale samples, each measuring 2 square centimeters (about the size of a thumbprint).
“Because this sample is used so ubiquitously—as in solar cells, organic field-effect transistors, and organic light-emitting diodes—if this material can be made to be thermally conductive, it can dissipate heat in all organic electronics,” Xu says.
The team measured each sample’s thermal conductivity using time-domain thermal reflectance—a technique in which it shoots a laser onto the material to heat up its surface and then monitor the drop in its surface temperature by measuring the material’s reflectance as the heat spreads into the material.
“The temporal profile of the decay of surface temperature is related to the speed of heat spreading, from which we were able to compute the thermal conductivity,” Zhou says.
On average, the polymer samples were able to conduct heat at about 2 watts per meter per kelvin, about 10 times faster than what conventional polymers can achieve. At Argonne National Laboratory, Jiang and Xu found that polymer samples appeared nearly isotropic, or uniform. This suggests that the material’s properties, such as its thermal conductivity, should also be nearly uniform. Following this reasoning, the team predicted that the material should conduct heat equally well in all directions, increasing its heat-dissipating potential.
Going forward, the team will continue exploring the fundamental physics behind polymer conductivity, as well as ways to enable the material to be used in electronics and other products, such as casings for batteries, and films for printed circuit boards.
“We can directly and conformally coat this material onto silicon wafers and different electronic devices,” Xu says. “If we can understand how thermal transport [works] in these disordered structures, maybe we can also push for higher thermal conductivity. Then we can help to resolve this widespread overheating problem, and provide better thermal management.”
This research was supported, in part, by the U.S. Department of Energy—Basic Energy Sciences and the MIT Deshpande Center.